September 28, 2012

Marian Dogma: Kiddie Style

Dear Protestant Friends,

Today, I would like to ask of you a favor. I would like for you to ask your child -- or some child -- the question, "Who is Jesus?" After you listen to the answer, I'm sure you will respond with many wonderful things for which we agree. I would request that you would only be careful to mention that Jesus is our brother (Hebrews 2).

This news should delight the child. Then I would only ask for you to remind the child that Jesus's mother is Mary. After which, ask the child, "Is Mary our Mother?"

The child's response should tell it all.

St. Paul tells us that God confounds the wise with the simple things. Ironically, the complexity of Catholic Marian dogma can be reduced to this most simple, basic intuition: Theotokos. It sounds very greek, and that is because it is, but one shouldn't confuse it for a complex theological insight. The complexity of Catholic dogma works in reverse: God reveals Himself to us in what appears at first blush little, simple ways.

A baby.

A tree.

Water.

Then we realize it is God we are dealing with and not a small child. Thus, as soon as we begin to meditate upon what it is that God reveals, we realize that the baby is God, the tree is eternal life, and that the water will soak through our skin. Revelation doesn't mean simplicity, it just means that God makes apprehensible what otherwise would not be apprehensible. 

If you are struggling with Marian dogma, I would encourage you to take two steps back and make sure you understand the first intuition. Look. There.

Here.
See. I told you it wasn't so bad.

Peace to you on your journey

September 25, 2012

September 21, 2012

Why I Do Not Respond to Everybody

1. I somehow missed your comment.

"I can answer your question,
don't you know." - internet person
2. I do not have time to respond. If you need a response, that is what the internets is for. I'm sure there is someone out there in the internets who would be happy to talk to you.

3. Your comment is not worth a response. That means, your argument is not strong enough to even consider putting my hand to the keyboard.

4. You are making comments that are irrelevant to the post to which your comment is posted.

5. I accidentally deleted your comment.

For all my readers, the new comment moderation was put into effect because I had someone spending all of the waking moments of his or her life posting red-bull induced, anti-Catholic, worn-out-fundamentalist comments. Then, this person decided to contact me directly and tell me that they would "never leave me alone".

Scary stuff.

I also have another poster who feels that he is qualified to debate the Pope, the college of Bishops or anyone, anytime, anywhere. That guy is a real stud. I wish I were that studly. I guess I will just have to be married for 10 years, have five kids, and a good job. Let me openly admit something -- right out loud on the internets. I am not qualified to debate the Pope, the college of Bishops, AND I do not have time to debate internet peoples.

Rule #1: Do not start something you cannot finish.

So, why don't I respond to everybody?

See "Rule #1".


September 20, 2012

Blog Idea Light: The Saints. The Bible.

I am working on a larger version of this post (in-between battling all manner of illness, working my tail off, and enjoying college football season and a really cute two month old), but I wanted to leave you a small tidbit to think about. One of the central tenants of Protestantism is that the Bible deserves to be with the people. It is the common man's Book. This little meme is meant to contravene certain clerical notions of Catholicism. The short question I have for my Protestant friends, is where is their St. Theresa of Avila?

Doctor of the Catholic faith
Seriously. I have recently become aware of the fact that all "leaders" of the Protestant faith are trained theologians. Even groups that use to disavow education now proudly announce their academic credentials. Then there is St. Theresa of Avila.

"We Prots believe the Bible is for the everyday man!" - Dr. Albert Fisher, Dean of the School of Theology

Enters St. Theresa of Avila.

Awkward moment.


September 10, 2012

Suffering


The scandal of the gospel is that Christ came simultaneously as a sufferer and for the suffering. And at that and to make matters more confusedly interesting, most suffering is senseless. Even pain at the expense of a hot stove is senseless. Although we can derive meaning from it -- that we should not put our hand here or there -- it is senseless nonetheless. 

This idea, that suffering is senseless, is kind of counter linguistic, for the phrase "senseless" implies that what is at stake is something without sense. Yet, as we know, suffering is far from sense-less. In fact, it is full of sensuosity. Instead, what we mean by this phrase "senseless" is that suffering is outside of the pale of normal human endeavor. As sensuous animals, we do not try for it (unless of course we are pathological). In other words, suffering, as such, is not a sense for which we try to grasp, but rather the very thing for which we try to avoid.

"No pain, no gain." 

A voice from the crowd chimes in, right at this moment in this blog post, to get a rise. I say that the adage doesn't approach what we mean by suffering. No one sticks his hand on a stove to grow. No one chooses cancer.

No, it is counterintuitive to embrace suffering. It is a scandal to our human appetites. It is upside down.

It is God hanging on a tree. Dead.

SUCCESS 
And if that Successory poster was not enough for you, watch the history of His followers unfold. Upside down versions of above, boiling vats of oil, death in childbirth, short lives. Sign me up, right? We don't sign up. Just turn on the television, to find out what we prefer:

He's like way awesome.

And we wonder why western civilization sits at the dawn of its extinction.

So what spurred this post? Two things.

First, all of my children are or have been sick. Throwing up. It has been miserable. Work has been good, honest, but grueling. It has been raining. My knee hurts on and off. Now, I don't mention all of this to complain. I'm not complaining. I'm telling you what motivated me to write this post. Remember?

Second, I'm reminded of my conversion to the Catholic faith. It is almost four years now. It was a conversion, despite my already converted heart to Christ. In a way, it represents my complete and total conversion to Christ. Why?

Because the Church holds up suffering as she does. She holds it up high, as high as her founder held it. She reminds all of us that the cross is both our history and our destiny. That the kings of this world have it all wrong, and that the king of this world had it all right. Yes, he asks us, "Will you live for me?" But unless that grain of wheat die, it can never live.

So I return to my opening theme.

Will we turn away from suffering disgusted? Or, will we see something more? As Catholics, the Church asks us to see something more. To see our connectedness, not only with each other, but ultimately with the One for whom bore the marks of our temporal suffering to make those marks fill up an eternal scale.

I struggle to succumb to my human appetites. I want to turn away from suffering. I thank God for Mother Church -- and for Her Lord that will never lead her away from the cross. Even St. John noticed a lamb slain in heaven. Let us not forget.

Amen.

September 4, 2012

Where I've Been

Well guys, I imagine you are thinking:

"I use to read this really neat-o blog called Almost Not Catholic, but now it appears that he has gone the way of the vandapool."

Shall we call it "vandapooling"?

Vandapooling (verb): starting a blog, only to realize that it was a bad idea, and then closing it down. Having free time again.

Example sentence:

"Brent created www.almostnotcatholic.com, only to vandapool everyone."

Another example:

"Guess what guys? I just started this awesome blog about blah, blah, blah called www.blahblah.com. Just kidding. I totally just vandapooled you!"

No, I'm not doing that.

My family is two months into #operationhavefivekids (<---yes, I just used a twitter hash tag in my post). A part of #operationhavefivekids is having a 2 month old, which is a lot of work. Also, a part of #operationhavefivekids is #operationfeedfivekids. That requires a lot of work. So, that is what I'm doing = revenue generating work ≠ blogging.

I am working on a post, and have a few more for which I am ruminating.

In the mean time, pray for me and I will pray for you. And...

Ora Pro Nobis!